Do you ever just want to pretend you are sitting on a beach, watching the ocean waves, sipping on a tropical cocktail? Well, this Painkiller Cocktail is exactly what will help you do so! Filled with delicious flavors of rum, pineapple juice, orange juice and coconut milk, this tropical drink is one for the books! Easy to make and even easier to drink!

The Painkiller cocktail is one of those classic tropical drinks that instantly tastes like vacation—creamy, fruity, and sunshine-bright with every sip. Often grouped with tiki-style favorites, it became famous for the way it blends bold rum with juicy pineapple and orange, finished with a fragrant dusting of nutmeg. The drink is strongly associated with the Soggy Dollar Bar, where it’s widely credited as being created (and popularized) in the 1970s on White Bay—an iconic beach setting that helped cement the Painkiller’s reputation as the ultimate “toes-in-the-sand” cocktail.

Part of what makes this recipe so legendary is how simple it is: dark rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, coconut milk/cream of coconut, and nutmeg. The pineapple brings tropical sweetness, the orange adds bright citrus lift, and the coconut element creates that dreamy, silky body that feels like a beach resort drink in your hand. When you top it with freshly grated nutmeg, you get an aromatic finish that makes the whole cocktail smell as good as it tastes—warm, cozy, and just a little exotic.

If you want the most authentic flavor, Pusser’s Rum is the best dark rum to use. It’s the rum most famously linked to the Painkiller and is commonly specified in widely published “classic” versions of the recipe. That deeper, richer rum profile is what keeps the drink from tasting like plain juice—it gives the cocktail structure, warmth, and a true Caribbean vibe.

This is the kind of drink that’s perfect for summer but honestly works any time you want a quick mental getaway. Make it for pool days, beach weekends, backyard barbecues, or even a cozy “vacation-at-home” moment when you’re craving tropical flavors. Served over crushed ice (or lots of ice), it stays frosty and refreshing—exactly what you want when the weather is hot, the music is on, and you’re in full chill mode.

Painkiller Cocktail Ingredients

Dark rum (Pusser’s Rum recommended)
The signature base spirit. Dark rum adds richness and depth, and Pusser’s Rum is widely considered the go-to choice for a classic-style Painkiller.
Pineapple juice
The main tropical flavor—sweet, bright, and juicy. It gives the Painkiller its sunshine-forward taste and helps create a smooth, fruity body.
Orange juice
Adds citrus lift and balances the pineapple sweetness so the drink tastes fresh and not overly sugary.
Coconut milk (or cream of coconut for a richer classic texture)
Coconut is what makes the drink creamy and “vacation-like.” Coconut milk works, but cream of coconut is thicker and sweeter, creating that classic silky mouthfeel many recipes are known for.
Freshly grated nutmeg (for the top)
The iconic finishing touch—warm, aromatic, and unmistakably “Painkiller.”

Step-by-Step: How to Make a Classic Painkiller

Measurements (1 cocktail):

2 oz dark rum (Pusser’s recommended)
4 oz pineapple juice
1 oz orange juice
1 oz coconut milk or cream of coconut (classic, richer option)
Freshly grated nutmeg, to top

Directions:

Fill your shaker with ice. (Crushed ice is great if you have it, but cubes work perfectly.)
Add the rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, and coconut milk/cream of coconut to the shaker.
Shake vigorously for 15–20 seconds, until the shaker feels very cold and the mixture looks creamy.
Strain (or pour) into a glass filled with ice. A tall glass works great here.
Top with freshly grated nutmeg and serve immediately (optional garnish: pineapple wedge or orange slice).

What Is In A Painkiller Cocktail?

Dark Rum – make sure to get yourself a good high quality dark rum, as this is your main alcoholic ingredient in this drink, and you sure don’t want to be sipping on something cheap! You don’t have to break the bank, but definitely don’t go for the non name brands!

Pineapple Juice – The delicious flavors of Pineapple Juice truly make this cocktail! You will taste even a little bit of a Pina Colada taste in this drink!

Orange Juice – Don’t go too heavy on this juice, but make sure you have enough in there to truly get that citrusy flavor in this tropical drink!

Coconut Milk – This is going to bring this drink to the next level, giving it that Caribbean vibe just like a Pina Colada

Nutmeg – This is solely for the Garnish on top, so if you are not a Nutmeg fan, then you can leave this off! Completely up to you!

Coconut Cream Or Coconut Milk?

You can use either coconut cream or coconut milk to make a this Painkiller Cocktail. You can even use coconut water if you don’t want the creamy texture. However, using coconut water will change the taste a bit, as it may not be as flavorful! The main difference between the cream and milk will be the texture. Coconut Cream has more of a frosting pasty texture to it and the milk is more smooth, just like a regular milk or half and half.

What Tools Will You Need To Make A Painkiller Cocktail?

Want To Make This For A Party?

Batched Painkiller Cocktail (Serve-a-Crowd Pitcher or Dispenser Version)

If you’re hosting a summer party, beach weekend, pool day, or tropical-themed gathering, making a batched Painkiller cocktail is the easiest way to keep the drinks flowing without playing bartender all day. This classic rum cocktail is ideal for batching because the flavors blend beautifully ahead of time, allowing the pineapple juice, orange juice, coconut, and dark rum to meld into one smooth, creamy, vacation-ready drink. Whether served from a large pitcher or a drink dispenser, this recipe delivers consistent flavor in every glass.

A batched Painkiller is perfect for self-serve cocktail stations, backyard barbecues, and relaxed entertaining. Using Pusser’s Rum in a large batch keeps the cocktail tasting rich and authentic, while chilling the mixture ahead of time ensures it stays refreshing even on the hottest summer days. For best results, keep the mixture cold and serve over ice, topping each glass with freshly grated nutmeg just before serving for that signature Painkiller finish.

Batched Painkiller Ingredients (Serves 8–12)

3 cups dark rum (Pusser’s Rum recommended)
6 cups pineapple juice
1½ cups orange juice
1½ cups coconut milk or cream of coconut (cream of coconut for a richer, more classic texture)
Freshly grated nutmeg, for topping
Ice, for serving

Optional garnishes: pineapple wedges or orange slices

How to Make a Batched Painkiller (Pitcher or Dispenser)

Combine the ingredients
In a large pitcher or mixing bowl, add the dark rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, and coconut milk or cream of coconut.
Stir until smooth
Stir thoroughly to fully incorporate the coconut and ensure the mixture is smooth and evenly blended.
Chill the mixture
Cover and refrigerate for at least 2–4 hours before serving so the cocktail is well chilled and flavors are fully developed.
Transfer to pitcher or dispenser
Pour the chilled mixture into a pitcher or drink dispenser when ready to serve.
Serve over ice
Fill glasses completely with ice and pour the Painkiller over the top.
Finish with nutmeg
Lightly sprinkle freshly grated nutmeg on each glass just before serving for the classic aroma and flavor.

Watch How It’s Made

View this post on Instagram